Gen. McChrystal has made it one of his efforts to reduce the amount of civilian casualties in the Afghan War (wrongfully titled "Obama's War" on the Washington Post website). You can't help but applaud the guy for focusing his attention on what other military analysts call "collateral damage." Yet, there are a couple of things to make this a perilous situation for our troops.
The Post says, "Under a tactical directive McChrystal issued last summer, troops must verify that there are no civilians inside a house by watching it for at least 72 hours to establish a "pattern of life" before an airstrike will be authorized." However, if soldiers are under imminent threat and cannot proceed without an airstrike, one will be granted.
I'm just cautious about the "pattern of life" definition within 72 hours, due to the old adage that you strike when the iron is hot. Is 72 hours too much time to assess whether or not there is a "pattern of life"? I mean, you can find countless examples (Somalia for one) when the Rear Echelon decided in their infinite wisdom that more lethal use of force in the heat of the moment is not appropriate. I'm concerned that when the boots on the ground see a particular hotbed of activity that the chain of command with nix the idea because it hasn't mean the "pattern of life" minimum. Not having been on a battlefield, I'm speaking only in speculative terms, but I think there is reason to be apprehensive.
No matter the situation or how benevolent the purpose is, whether it be corporate America or the battlefield, when blanket policies are enforced, something is bound to run amok. How is this going to affect our troops in harm's way? How is the Taliban going to use this against us to prevent the use of airstrikes moving forward?
I'm not an expert, nor do I claim to be, but this makes me feel a little uneasy. I applaud Gen. McChrystal's efforts to reduce civilian casualties because, well, that's just human. But in this circumstance, is this the best that can be done?
No comments:
Post a Comment