Saturday, February 20, 2010

Marja and Where Is This Going?

Rajiv Chandrasekaran wrote a good piece in the Washington Post this afternoon about the current situation facing Marines and the Helmand Province. (Read it here)

I want to make note of a couple of things that are troubling me about the situation in Marja, as reported by the press. It's the best reference I can come up with since I'm not in the area.

First. In 2000, Marja produced 10% of the world's illegal opium production. Once known as "Little America" due to the irrigation technology and canals American installed in the 1950's, Pashtun influence quickly influenced farmers away from wheat production to poppies. Accordingly, a tremendous amount of Taliban funds comes from opium sales and this region.

Chandreasekaran notes that the once filled bazaars for this region of 85,000 citizens are empty since the Brits and Americans have conducted raids to nab Taliban leaders from 2008. Now given the 2010 Marine Offensive, these markets are understandably empty again for fear of being in the middle of a firefight. He also notes that Lt. Col. Cal Worth waited to speak to some of the merchants to urge going back to work once the dust settles (literally and figuratively).

Well what are the merchants selling? Among other things, poppy paste sold to drug traffickers for worldwide consumption.

The point I'm trying to make here is that if this is a land that produces 10% of the world's opium, and the markets are selling poppy paste to illicit drug traffickers, what are the merchants going to sell now? What is the farming alternative for these poor folks who are pressured into opium production in the first place? They can probably earn more money selling poppies than bushels of wheat, but then again, I'm not an agrarian farmer, so I don't know the monetary specifics.

The thing that troubles me about this situation is that yes, getting the people back in the bazaars and establishing a functional economy is a good thing. However, if we dissuade and enforce them not to grow poppies, how does trading continue to exist? It isn't enough just to say that we want people to go back to work - we also have to make sure they have something to sell, with a reasonable demand.

Second. It is equally disturbing that Haji Zahir, who has been living in Germany for the past 15 years will now be the district governor. I haven't lived in Massachusetts for about 18 months, and I'm completely out of touch with the current political landscape even though I try to read boston.com as much as possible. How on earth is Zahir going to transition smoothly into a governing role? Further, are the residents of Marja going to go along with his governance? He's not even from Marja! Whatever happened to us trying to instill a democracy? Note: Zahir hasn't even been back - he's due to make his first trip in a couple of days.

Third. According to Chandrasekaran, the man with the most influence in the region is Abdul Rahman Jan, a brutal former police chief in Helmand. The residents of Marja were more in favor of the Taliban because of Jan's police force conducting "summary executions." He still has his hands in the illicit narco trade, but alas, he's good buddies with Karzai. If Karzai really wants this guy to be the leader in Marja, we're in for a world of hurt. Do we really think that this region is going to get back on its feet without a sound alternative to poppy farming and a former terrorizer coming back to the governing ranks?

My fear is that this Offensive was not clearly thought out. I don't mean military - I hope that our people in command know how to drive the insurgents out and take hold of the area. I'm talking about the after effects. Once the Taliban is driven out, how do we continue to prevent the insurgency from coming back in? If we think that putting Jan back in power and continuing his business as usual is going to get things back on track, I'm afraid that we are probably mistaken.

According to John Kael Weston of the State Department, "Marja will be a test for everyone." Well I'd say that's probably an understatement. The locals have seen the US and Great Britain come in and leave at least twice, and now they want to trust us that we'll be there for many months. We helped get rid of the former Soviet Union, and then left - like Tom and Daisy in The Great Gatsby, letting everyone else clean up the mess.

I'd say this is going to be a test. It's going to be a test on a lot of different levels. The only thing I fear is that we have our troops fighting in a situation that has already counted 8 dead, and in the end, we'll have nothing to show for it. We'll just tell the vendors to go back to the markets, and continue business as usual even though there's nothing usual about it.



No comments:

Post a Comment